Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin ›› 2022, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (21): 58-69.doi: 10.11924/j.issn.1000-6850.casb2021-0747
Special Issue: 生物技术
Previous Articles Next Articles
QIE Tianzhen1,2(), LI Fu1,2, LI Yahua1,2, WANG Lifang1,2, ZHANG Tingting1,2, ZHANG Jiaqian1,2, WANG Hongwei3, ZHANG Dejian1,2(
)
Received:
2021-08-02
Revised:
2021-11-03
Online:
2022-07-25
Published:
2022-08-23
Contact:
ZHANG Dejian
E-mail:1798549105@qq.com;zhangdejian00@163.com
CLC Number:
QIE Tianzhen, LI Fu, LI Yahua, WANG Lifang, ZHANG Tingting, ZHANG Jiaqian, WANG Hongwei, ZHANG Dejian. Effects of Tillage Methods on Soil Chemical Properties Under Straw Returning Condition[J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(21): 58-69.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX
URL: https://www.casb.org.cn/EN/10.11924/j.issn.1000-6850.casb2021-0747
土壤化学指标 | 土层深度/cm | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
0~10 | 10~20 | 20~40 | 40~60 | |
有机碳/(g/kg) | 4.11 | 4.65 | 3.39 | 3.63 |
碱解氮/(mg/kg) | 40.67 | 35.00 | 32.57 | 14.67 |
速效磷/(mg/kg) | 4.79 | 2.23 | 0.77 | 1.04 |
速效钾/(mg/kg) | 6.27 | 4.13 | 3.87 | 3.22 |
全氮/(g/kg) | 1.95 | 1.92 | 1.43 | 0.74 |
全磷/(g/kg) | 4.56 | 3.21 | 2.98 | 2.57 |
全钾/(g/kg) | 34.52 | 31.76 | 25.43 | 19.81 |
土壤化学指标 | 土层深度/cm | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
0~10 | 10~20 | 20~40 | 40~60 | |
有机碳/(g/kg) | 4.11 | 4.65 | 3.39 | 3.63 |
碱解氮/(mg/kg) | 40.67 | 35.00 | 32.57 | 14.67 |
速效磷/(mg/kg) | 4.79 | 2.23 | 0.77 | 1.04 |
速效钾/(mg/kg) | 6.27 | 4.13 | 3.87 | 3.22 |
全氮/(g/kg) | 1.95 | 1.92 | 1.43 | 0.74 |
全磷/(g/kg) | 4.56 | 3.21 | 2.98 | 2.57 |
全钾/(g/kg) | 34.52 | 31.76 | 25.43 | 19.81 |
编号 | 处理 | 具体方案 |
---|---|---|
CK | 秸秆不还田+传统翻耕 | 秋季收获后秸秆全部清除,然后浅翻+重耙。翌年重耙播种。 |
SDH | 秸秆全量深翻还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田并深翻30 cm以上,然后重耙。 |
SSH | 秸秆全量深松还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田深松25~30 cm,并重耙。 |
SSS | 秸秆全量深松浅翻还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田深松浅翻,深松25~30 cm,浅翻15~20 cm,翌年重耙播种。 |
SH | 秸秆全量重耙还田 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田,利用重耙耙地,耙深8~15 cm,翌年重耙播种。 |
SRT | 秸秆全量旋耕还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田,利用旋耕机整地,耕深8~15 cm,翌年重耙播种。 |
SZT | 秸秆全量免耕还田 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田,秸秆覆盖于地表。 |
编号 | 处理 | 具体方案 |
---|---|---|
CK | 秸秆不还田+传统翻耕 | 秋季收获后秸秆全部清除,然后浅翻+重耙。翌年重耙播种。 |
SDH | 秸秆全量深翻还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田并深翻30 cm以上,然后重耙。 |
SSH | 秸秆全量深松还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田深松25~30 cm,并重耙。 |
SSS | 秸秆全量深松浅翻还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田深松浅翻,深松25~30 cm,浅翻15~20 cm,翌年重耙播种。 |
SH | 秸秆全量重耙还田 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田,利用重耙耙地,耙深8~15 cm,翌年重耙播种。 |
SRT | 秸秆全量旋耕还田+重耙 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田,利用旋耕机整地,耕深8~15 cm,翌年重耙播种。 |
SZT | 秸秆全量免耕还田 | 秋季收获后秸秆切碎还田,秸秆覆盖于地表。 |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 23.40±0.00f | 30.78±1.18abc | 24.42±0.44ab | 25.03±0.64a |
SDH | 33.58±0.00bc | 26.27±1.54d | 20.03±0.33cd | 11.90±0.48c | ||
SSH | 30.70±1.23d | 34.25±1.15a | 26.18±0.99a | 15.49±1.55bc | ||
SSS | 40.68±0.22a | 27.15±0.22cd | 22.19±0.58bcd | 11.11±0.65c | ||
SH | 32.14±0.91cd | 28.82±0.22bcd | 24.69±0.43ab | 16.96±0.60b | ||
SRT | 35.13±0.59b | 31.34±1.95ab | 19.53±0.30d | 12.04±1.93c | ||
SZT | 27.38±0.59e | 32.25±0.66ab | 23.69±0.29abc | 12.17±0.61c | ||
收获期 | CK | 28.60±0.77abc | 28.82±0.97a | 16.79±0.44b | 14.50±0.27b | |
SDH | 25.60±1.02c | 26.71±1.23a | 25.85±0.83a | 26.13±0.40a | ||
SSH | 30.92±0.00a | 27.60±0.67a | 15.05±0.60bc | 12.04±0.13c | ||
SSS | 28.48±1.89abc | 27.60±0.33a | 14.13±0.17c | 12.77±1.06c | ||
SH | 29.48±0.44ab | 29.04±0.59a | 24.94±0.29a | 11.31±0.13c | ||
SRT | 27.04±0.22bc | 28.15±0.59a | 24.61±0.44a | 15.03±0.13b | ||
SZT | 21.50±0.44d | 23.72±0.97b | 13.80±1.01c | 12.10±0.35c | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 32.13±1.70cd | 31.07±0.85b | 21.07±0.48cd | 14.56±0.22c |
SDH | 31.49±0.43d | 33.84±0.64b | 28.57±0.58a | 15.07±0.34c | ||
SSH | 36.39±0.37b | 32.98±0.77b | 26.01±0.16b | 13.66±0.34c | ||
SSS | 34.05±0.56bcd | 31.92±0.37b | 21.23±0.16c | 14.68±0.13c | ||
SH | 41.50±0.37a | 28.94±0.56b | 19.47±0.42d | 13.66±0.89c | ||
SRT | 34.69±0.77bc | 37.45±1.83a | 29.05±0.58a | 23.24±0.51a | ||
SZT | 32.56±0.98cd | 31.49±1.49b | 20.91±0.70cd | 18.26±0.64b | ||
收获期 | CK | 35.90±0.75a | 34.77±0.75a | 18.84±0.97b | 17.97±1.45b | |
SDH | 28.52±0.49bc | 31.08±1.3abc | 16.29±0.64bc | 23.58±1.76a | ||
SSH | 24.55±0.75d | 26.26±1.02c | 13.10±1.68c | 16.43±0.90b | ||
SSS | 26.82±0.85cd | 29.09±0.75bc | 14.16±1.82bc | 15.24±0.61b | ||
SH | 31.08±1.25b | 33.91±1.88ab | 17.99±0.21bc | 28.18±0.74a | ||
SRT | 31.36±0.28b | 33.91±1.73ab | 26.01±0.16a | 16.73±0.13b | ||
SZT | 25.96±0.21cd | 29.66±0.28abc | 17.56±0.64bc | 25.97±0.61a |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 23.40±0.00f | 30.78±1.18abc | 24.42±0.44ab | 25.03±0.64a |
SDH | 33.58±0.00bc | 26.27±1.54d | 20.03±0.33cd | 11.90±0.48c | ||
SSH | 30.70±1.23d | 34.25±1.15a | 26.18±0.99a | 15.49±1.55bc | ||
SSS | 40.68±0.22a | 27.15±0.22cd | 22.19±0.58bcd | 11.11±0.65c | ||
SH | 32.14±0.91cd | 28.82±0.22bcd | 24.69±0.43ab | 16.96±0.60b | ||
SRT | 35.13±0.59b | 31.34±1.95ab | 19.53±0.30d | 12.04±1.93c | ||
SZT | 27.38±0.59e | 32.25±0.66ab | 23.69±0.29abc | 12.17±0.61c | ||
收获期 | CK | 28.60±0.77abc | 28.82±0.97a | 16.79±0.44b | 14.50±0.27b | |
SDH | 25.60±1.02c | 26.71±1.23a | 25.85±0.83a | 26.13±0.40a | ||
SSH | 30.92±0.00a | 27.60±0.67a | 15.05±0.60bc | 12.04±0.13c | ||
SSS | 28.48±1.89abc | 27.60±0.33a | 14.13±0.17c | 12.77±1.06c | ||
SH | 29.48±0.44ab | 29.04±0.59a | 24.94±0.29a | 11.31±0.13c | ||
SRT | 27.04±0.22bc | 28.15±0.59a | 24.61±0.44a | 15.03±0.13b | ||
SZT | 21.50±0.44d | 23.72±0.97b | 13.80±1.01c | 12.10±0.35c | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 32.13±1.70cd | 31.07±0.85b | 21.07±0.48cd | 14.56±0.22c |
SDH | 31.49±0.43d | 33.84±0.64b | 28.57±0.58a | 15.07±0.34c | ||
SSH | 36.39±0.37b | 32.98±0.77b | 26.01±0.16b | 13.66±0.34c | ||
SSS | 34.05±0.56bcd | 31.92±0.37b | 21.23±0.16c | 14.68±0.13c | ||
SH | 41.50±0.37a | 28.94±0.56b | 19.47±0.42d | 13.66±0.89c | ||
SRT | 34.69±0.77bc | 37.45±1.83a | 29.05±0.58a | 23.24±0.51a | ||
SZT | 32.56±0.98cd | 31.49±1.49b | 20.91±0.70cd | 18.26±0.64b | ||
收获期 | CK | 35.90±0.75a | 34.77±0.75a | 18.84±0.97b | 17.97±1.45b | |
SDH | 28.52±0.49bc | 31.08±1.3abc | 16.29±0.64bc | 23.58±1.76a | ||
SSH | 24.55±0.75d | 26.26±1.02c | 13.10±1.68c | 16.43±0.90b | ||
SSS | 26.82±0.85cd | 29.09±0.75bc | 14.16±1.82bc | 15.24±0.61b | ||
SH | 31.08±1.25b | 33.91±1.88ab | 17.99±0.21bc | 28.18±0.74a | ||
SRT | 31.36±0.28b | 33.91±1.73ab | 26.01±0.16a | 16.73±0.13b | ||
SZT | 25.96±0.21cd | 29.66±0.28abc | 17.56±0.64bc | 25.97±0.61a |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 42.67±0.88c | 34.00±1.53d | 33.17±1.74d | 16.67±0.33d |
SDH | 66.03±2.05b | 65.30±0.15b | 52.73±0.72b | 27.67±0.33b | ||
SSH | 77.67±0.33a | 76.67±1.70a | 57.66±1.76a | 34.33±0.67a | ||
SSS | 76.00±0.58a | 65.33±0.67b | 55.33±0.33ab | 34.67±0.33a | ||
SH | 63.00±1.53b | 55.33±0.67c | 41.00±1.00c | 21.33±0.33c | ||
SRT | 42.33±0.33c | 35.67±1.20d | 35.33±1.45d | 16.67±1.45d | ||
SZT | 66.00±0.00b | 65.00±1.15b | 37.67±2.03cd | 17.50±1.32d | ||
收获期 | CK | 60.83±1.38d | 54.00±2.08d | 42.17±0.44d | 12.83±1.01d | |
SDH | 83.03±0.55c | 71.50±1.26b | 62.90±2.80b | 25.33±0.67bc | ||
SSH | 122.17±1.17a | 87.00±1.04a | 66.43±0.30ab | 33.67±0.17a | ||
SSS | 120.33±1.09a | 71.97±1.52b | 68.33±0.44a | 36.33±0.73a | ||
SH | 101.00±0.29b | 64.17±1.01c | 51.67±0.60c | 28.00±0.29b | ||
SRT | 58.67±0.60d | 56.50±0.29d | 49.67±2.13c | 23.00±0.76c | ||
SZT | 81.17±0.93c | 68.50±0.50b | 54.50±1.32c | 25.83±2.13bc | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 39.01±1.00c | 36.83±0.88d | 16.17±0.85d | 14.50±0.73d |
SDH | 47.46±1.22ab | 50.17±0.84c | 32.83±1.20b | 23.17±0.88c | ||
SSH | 52.77±1.72a | 60.99±0.76a | 38.27±0.88a | 27.90±0.75b | ||
SSS | 50.53±0.72a | 61.08±1.43a | 37.97±1.25a | 32.33±0.84a | ||
SH | 43.38±1.30bc | 50.82±1.26c | 27.03±1.29c | 17.20±1.25d | ||
SRT | 40.34±0.93c | 35.86±1.47d | 16.81±0.84d | 13.95±0.89d | ||
SZT | 47.21±1.13ab | 56.78±0.79b | 24.96±1.14c | 17.39±1.22d | ||
收获期 | CK | 33.02±2.33c | 28.35±3.50d | 35.18±3.58b | 13.18±1.17d | |
SDH | 64.52±1.17a | 43.52±1.17ab | 36.52±1.17b | 37.68±2.33bc | ||
SSH | 65.68±1.17a | 44.68±1.17ab | 43.52±1.17ab | 41.18±1.17ab | ||
SSS | 70.35±2.02a | 52.85±2.35a | 52.85±2.02a | 47.02±2.33a | ||
SH | 64.52±3.09a | 44.68±2.33ab | 34.18±1.17b | 19.02±1.17d | ||
SRT | 49.35±2.02b | 35.52±0.24cd | 30.02±0.17b | 15.52±2.09d | ||
SZT | 66.85±2.02a | 44.18±2.59ab | 35.35±2.02b | 34.18±1.17c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 42.67±0.88c | 34.00±1.53d | 33.17±1.74d | 16.67±0.33d |
SDH | 66.03±2.05b | 65.30±0.15b | 52.73±0.72b | 27.67±0.33b | ||
SSH | 77.67±0.33a | 76.67±1.70a | 57.66±1.76a | 34.33±0.67a | ||
SSS | 76.00±0.58a | 65.33±0.67b | 55.33±0.33ab | 34.67±0.33a | ||
SH | 63.00±1.53b | 55.33±0.67c | 41.00±1.00c | 21.33±0.33c | ||
SRT | 42.33±0.33c | 35.67±1.20d | 35.33±1.45d | 16.67±1.45d | ||
SZT | 66.00±0.00b | 65.00±1.15b | 37.67±2.03cd | 17.50±1.32d | ||
收获期 | CK | 60.83±1.38d | 54.00±2.08d | 42.17±0.44d | 12.83±1.01d | |
SDH | 83.03±0.55c | 71.50±1.26b | 62.90±2.80b | 25.33±0.67bc | ||
SSH | 122.17±1.17a | 87.00±1.04a | 66.43±0.30ab | 33.67±0.17a | ||
SSS | 120.33±1.09a | 71.97±1.52b | 68.33±0.44a | 36.33±0.73a | ||
SH | 101.00±0.29b | 64.17±1.01c | 51.67±0.60c | 28.00±0.29b | ||
SRT | 58.67±0.60d | 56.50±0.29d | 49.67±2.13c | 23.00±0.76c | ||
SZT | 81.17±0.93c | 68.50±0.50b | 54.50±1.32c | 25.83±2.13bc | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 39.01±1.00c | 36.83±0.88d | 16.17±0.85d | 14.50±0.73d |
SDH | 47.46±1.22ab | 50.17±0.84c | 32.83±1.20b | 23.17±0.88c | ||
SSH | 52.77±1.72a | 60.99±0.76a | 38.27±0.88a | 27.90±0.75b | ||
SSS | 50.53±0.72a | 61.08±1.43a | 37.97±1.25a | 32.33±0.84a | ||
SH | 43.38±1.30bc | 50.82±1.26c | 27.03±1.29c | 17.20±1.25d | ||
SRT | 40.34±0.93c | 35.86±1.47d | 16.81±0.84d | 13.95±0.89d | ||
SZT | 47.21±1.13ab | 56.78±0.79b | 24.96±1.14c | 17.39±1.22d | ||
收获期 | CK | 33.02±2.33c | 28.35±3.50d | 35.18±3.58b | 13.18±1.17d | |
SDH | 64.52±1.17a | 43.52±1.17ab | 36.52±1.17b | 37.68±2.33bc | ||
SSH | 65.68±1.17a | 44.68±1.17ab | 43.52±1.17ab | 41.18±1.17ab | ||
SSS | 70.35±2.02a | 52.85±2.35a | 52.85±2.02a | 47.02±2.33a | ||
SH | 64.52±3.09a | 44.68±2.33ab | 34.18±1.17b | 19.02±1.17d | ||
SRT | 49.35±2.02b | 35.52±0.24cd | 30.02±0.17b | 15.52±2.09d | ||
SZT | 66.85±2.02a | 44.18±2.59ab | 35.35±2.02b | 34.18±1.17c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 4.99±0.00d | 3.11±0.00c | 0.98±0.01d | 1.10±0.00d |
SDH | 5.01±0.01c | 3.16±0.00c | 1.04±0.01c | 1.71±0.01b | ||
SSH | 5.34±0.00a | 3.78±0.00a | 1.47±0.00a | 1.78±0.00a | ||
SSS | 5.35±0.00a | 3.75±0.02a | 1.46±0.00a | 1.77±0.00a | ||
SH | 5.08±0.00b | 3.15±0.03c | 1.05±0.00c | 1.72±0.00b | ||
SRT | 4.97±0.01d | 2.33±0.01d | 1.00±0.00d | 1.09±0.00d | ||
SZT | 4.98±0.00d | 3.50±0.00b | 1.43±0.00b | 1.13±0.01c | ||
收获期 | CK | 8.67±0.01d | 4.12±0.01b | 2.26±0.01d | 1.82±0.01e | |
SDH | 8.96±0.00c | 4.30±0.04b | 2.86±0.01bcd | 1.96±0.01c | ||
SSH | 9.46±0.01b | 7.75±0.01a | 3.65±0.02ab | 2.71±0.01a | ||
SSS | 10.76±0.01a | 8.29±0.00a | 4.33±0.67a | 2.70±0.01a | ||
SH | 9.45±0.00b | 4.84±0.01b | 2.77±0.00cd | 1.89±0.04d | ||
SRT | 8.63±0.01d | 4.23±0.69b | 2.24±0.01d | 1.82±0.03e | ||
SZT | 9.43±0.02b | 5.10±0.33b | 3.18±0.04bc | 2.51±0.00b | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 8.73±0.19d | 5.78±0.12d | 3.49±0.53b | 3.58±0.57c |
SDH | 13.32±0.34c | 9.81±0.47c | 6.58±0.61ab | 4.00±0.24bc | ||
SSH | 26.01±0.87a | 13.33±0.41a | 7.28±0.33a | 5.74±0.82ab | ||
SSS | 18.89±0.85b | 12.90±0.28a | 6.62±0.13ab | 6.20±0.41a | ||
SH | 14.16±0.29c | 11.31±0.57b | 4.05±0.41ab | 4.71±0.59abc | ||
SRT | 8.82±0.63d | 8.87±0.51c | 3.77±0.62b | 3.82±0.23c | ||
SZT | 17.86±0.46b | 9.53±0.17c | 4.28±0.49ab | 3.82±0.58c | ||
收获期 | CK | 19.57±0.19d | 19.48±0.56c | 18.06±0.17d | 13.18±0.17d | |
SDH | 29.61±0.54b | 21.68±0.77b | 19.74±0.37c | 15.95±0.37c | ||
SSH | 33.05±0.47a | 26.62±0.43a | 28.03±0.42a | 30.22±0.35a | ||
SSS | 34.00±0.48a | 25.11±0.40a | 32.56±0.38a | 33.02±0.18a | ||
SH | 20.48±0.31d | 26.57±0.15a | 19.18±0.37cd | 19.17±0.35b | ||
SRT | 20.15±0.05d | 16.86±0.28d | 18.35±0.41d | 16.22±0.44c | ||
SZT | 24.84±0.12c | 18.14±0.17cd | 24.27±0.17b | 16.92±0.28c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 4.99±0.00d | 3.11±0.00c | 0.98±0.01d | 1.10±0.00d |
SDH | 5.01±0.01c | 3.16±0.00c | 1.04±0.01c | 1.71±0.01b | ||
SSH | 5.34±0.00a | 3.78±0.00a | 1.47±0.00a | 1.78±0.00a | ||
SSS | 5.35±0.00a | 3.75±0.02a | 1.46±0.00a | 1.77±0.00a | ||
SH | 5.08±0.00b | 3.15±0.03c | 1.05±0.00c | 1.72±0.00b | ||
SRT | 4.97±0.01d | 2.33±0.01d | 1.00±0.00d | 1.09±0.00d | ||
SZT | 4.98±0.00d | 3.50±0.00b | 1.43±0.00b | 1.13±0.01c | ||
收获期 | CK | 8.67±0.01d | 4.12±0.01b | 2.26±0.01d | 1.82±0.01e | |
SDH | 8.96±0.00c | 4.30±0.04b | 2.86±0.01bcd | 1.96±0.01c | ||
SSH | 9.46±0.01b | 7.75±0.01a | 3.65±0.02ab | 2.71±0.01a | ||
SSS | 10.76±0.01a | 8.29±0.00a | 4.33±0.67a | 2.70±0.01a | ||
SH | 9.45±0.00b | 4.84±0.01b | 2.77±0.00cd | 1.89±0.04d | ||
SRT | 8.63±0.01d | 4.23±0.69b | 2.24±0.01d | 1.82±0.03e | ||
SZT | 9.43±0.02b | 5.10±0.33b | 3.18±0.04bc | 2.51±0.00b | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 8.73±0.19d | 5.78±0.12d | 3.49±0.53b | 3.58±0.57c |
SDH | 13.32±0.34c | 9.81±0.47c | 6.58±0.61ab | 4.00±0.24bc | ||
SSH | 26.01±0.87a | 13.33±0.41a | 7.28±0.33a | 5.74±0.82ab | ||
SSS | 18.89±0.85b | 12.90±0.28a | 6.62±0.13ab | 6.20±0.41a | ||
SH | 14.16±0.29c | 11.31±0.57b | 4.05±0.41ab | 4.71±0.59abc | ||
SRT | 8.82±0.63d | 8.87±0.51c | 3.77±0.62b | 3.82±0.23c | ||
SZT | 17.86±0.46b | 9.53±0.17c | 4.28±0.49ab | 3.82±0.58c | ||
收获期 | CK | 19.57±0.19d | 19.48±0.56c | 18.06±0.17d | 13.18±0.17d | |
SDH | 29.61±0.54b | 21.68±0.77b | 19.74±0.37c | 15.95±0.37c | ||
SSH | 33.05±0.47a | 26.62±0.43a | 28.03±0.42a | 30.22±0.35a | ||
SSS | 34.00±0.48a | 25.11±0.40a | 32.56±0.38a | 33.02±0.18a | ||
SH | 20.48±0.31d | 26.57±0.15a | 19.18±0.37cd | 19.17±0.35b | ||
SRT | 20.15±0.05d | 16.86±0.28d | 18.35±0.41d | 16.22±0.44c | ||
SZT | 24.84±0.12c | 18.14±0.17cd | 24.27±0.17b | 16.92±0.28c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 6.48±0.00d | 3.52±0.00d | 3.32±0.00d | 3.02±0.00e |
SDH | 7.85±0.04b | 4.37±0.02c | 3.91±0.01c | 3.48±0.01c | ||
SSH | 8.12±0.00a | 6.05±0.00a | 4.45±0.01b | 4.04±0.01a | ||
SSS | 8.10±0.05a | 5.84±0.00a | 4.57±0.01a | 4.06±0.00a | ||
SH | 7.90±0.01b | 4.89±0.36b | 3.91±0.01c | 3.71±0.00b | ||
SRT | 6.99±0.00b | 4.36±0.07c | 3.35±0.01d | 2.99±0.00e | ||
SZT | 7.04±0.00b | 4.79±0.02bc | 4.42±0.00b | 3.32±0.02d | ||
收获期 | CK | 7.61±0.01d | 6.89±0.00d | 5.91±0.03d | 5.75±0.11de | |
SDH | 9.11±0.04b | 7.24±0.03c | 6.10±0.02c | 6.02±0.08bc | ||
SSH | 10.27±0.03a | 7.54±0.01a | 6.75±0.03a | 6.18±0.08ab | ||
SSS | 10.15±0.08a | 7.58±0.01a | 6.35±0.00b | 6.41±0.01a | ||
SH | 8.44±0.01c | 7.42±0.04b | 6.29±0.01b | 5.80±0.07cd | ||
SRT | 7.67±0.02d | 6.92±0.01d | 5.90±0.00d | 5.55±0.01e | ||
SZT | 8.41±0.00c | 7.35±0.04b | 6.08±0.00c | 5.67±0.05de | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 5.12±0.01d | 4.46±0.03e | 3.08±0.04d | 3.57±0.01c |
SDH | 5.89±0.03c | 4.95±0.04c | 3.63±0.06c | 3.96±0.05b | ||
SSH | 6.88±0.16a | 5.69±0.05a | 4.20±0.01a | 4.36±0.02a | ||
SSS | 6.89±0.05a | 5.15±0.05b | 3.78±0.03b | 4.36±0.03a | ||
SH | 6.49±0.04b | 4.84±0.02cd | 3.57±0.04c | 4.01±0.03b | ||
SRT | 5.65±0.06c | 4.53±0.03e | 3.55±0.05c | 3.08±0.06d | ||
SZT | 6.48±0.13b | 4.72±0.02d | 3.56±0.04c | 4.05±0.06b | ||
收获期 | CK | 8.12±0.01e | 7.58±0.01d | 6.68±0.03d | 5.83±0.01d | |
SDH | 9.77±0.08b | 7.62±0.08d | 7.55±0.01b | 6.52±0.04bc | ||
SSH | 10.05±0.01a | 9.33±0.05a | 8.20±0.11a | 7.52±0.01a | ||
SSS | 10.01±0.01a | 9.24±0.01a | 8.18±0.02a | 7.48±0.06a | ||
SH | 8.84±0.02c | 9.00±0.01b | 7.41±0.06b | 7.11±0.04b | ||
SRT | 8.19±0.05de | 7.57±0.05d | 6.74±0.02d | 5.93±0.01d | ||
SZT | 8.26±0.00d | 8.68±0.01c | 6.96±0.02c | 6.52±0.01c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 6.48±0.00d | 3.52±0.00d | 3.32±0.00d | 3.02±0.00e |
SDH | 7.85±0.04b | 4.37±0.02c | 3.91±0.01c | 3.48±0.01c | ||
SSH | 8.12±0.00a | 6.05±0.00a | 4.45±0.01b | 4.04±0.01a | ||
SSS | 8.10±0.05a | 5.84±0.00a | 4.57±0.01a | 4.06±0.00a | ||
SH | 7.90±0.01b | 4.89±0.36b | 3.91±0.01c | 3.71±0.00b | ||
SRT | 6.99±0.00b | 4.36±0.07c | 3.35±0.01d | 2.99±0.00e | ||
SZT | 7.04±0.00b | 4.79±0.02bc | 4.42±0.00b | 3.32±0.02d | ||
收获期 | CK | 7.61±0.01d | 6.89±0.00d | 5.91±0.03d | 5.75±0.11de | |
SDH | 9.11±0.04b | 7.24±0.03c | 6.10±0.02c | 6.02±0.08bc | ||
SSH | 10.27±0.03a | 7.54±0.01a | 6.75±0.03a | 6.18±0.08ab | ||
SSS | 10.15±0.08a | 7.58±0.01a | 6.35±0.00b | 6.41±0.01a | ||
SH | 8.44±0.01c | 7.42±0.04b | 6.29±0.01b | 5.80±0.07cd | ||
SRT | 7.67±0.02d | 6.92±0.01d | 5.90±0.00d | 5.55±0.01e | ||
SZT | 8.41±0.00c | 7.35±0.04b | 6.08±0.00c | 5.67±0.05de | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 5.12±0.01d | 4.46±0.03e | 3.08±0.04d | 3.57±0.01c |
SDH | 5.89±0.03c | 4.95±0.04c | 3.63±0.06c | 3.96±0.05b | ||
SSH | 6.88±0.16a | 5.69±0.05a | 4.20±0.01a | 4.36±0.02a | ||
SSS | 6.89±0.05a | 5.15±0.05b | 3.78±0.03b | 4.36±0.03a | ||
SH | 6.49±0.04b | 4.84±0.02cd | 3.57±0.04c | 4.01±0.03b | ||
SRT | 5.65±0.06c | 4.53±0.03e | 3.55±0.05c | 3.08±0.06d | ||
SZT | 6.48±0.13b | 4.72±0.02d | 3.56±0.04c | 4.05±0.06b | ||
收获期 | CK | 8.12±0.01e | 7.58±0.01d | 6.68±0.03d | 5.83±0.01d | |
SDH | 9.77±0.08b | 7.62±0.08d | 7.55±0.01b | 6.52±0.04bc | ||
SSH | 10.05±0.01a | 9.33±0.05a | 8.20±0.11a | 7.52±0.01a | ||
SSS | 10.01±0.01a | 9.24±0.01a | 8.18±0.02a | 7.48±0.06a | ||
SH | 8.84±0.02c | 9.00±0.01b | 7.41±0.06b | 7.11±0.04b | ||
SRT | 8.19±0.05de | 7.57±0.05d | 6.74±0.02d | 5.93±0.01d | ||
SZT | 8.26±0.00d | 8.68±0.01c | 6.96±0.02c | 6.52±0.01c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 2.11±0.02bc | 1.91±0.01c | 1.71±0.02b | 0.88±0.03c |
SDH | 2.24±0.05ab | 1.98±0.01bc | 1.74±0.02ab | 1.48±0.01a | ||
SSH | 2.33±0.05a | 2.10±0.05a | 1.82±0.05a | 1.57±0.01a | ||
SSS | 2.33±0.04a | 2.05±0.01b | 1.79±0.01ab | 1.54±0.03a | ||
SH | 2.25±0.02ab | 1.99±0.04bc | 1.75±0.01ab | 1.54±0.01a | ||
SRT | 2.06±0.05c | 1.98±0.06bc | 1.74±0.03ab | 0.77±0.02d | ||
SZT | 2.28±0.04a | 1.97±0.03bc | 1.76±0.03ab | 1.24±0.02b | ||
收获期 | CK | 3.14±0.01e | 2.63±0.00d | 2.08±0.01e | 1.71±0.03c | |
SDH | 3.25±0.02d | 2.91±0.01c | 2.34±0.01d | 1.94±0.02b | ||
SSH | 3.46±0.03b | 3.08±0.01ab | 2.67±0.02a | 2.42±0.01a | ||
SSS | 3.57±0.02a | 3.12±0.03a | 2.72±0.03a | 2.07±0.02a | ||
SH | 3.35±0.02c | 3.05±0.00b | 2.43±0.01c | 1.88±0.05b | ||
SRT | 3.07±0.01e | 2.67±0.01d | 2.08±0.01e | 1.13±0.05d | ||
SZT | 3.49±0.00b | 2.95±0.01c | 2.54±0.02b | 1.89±0.03b | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 2.17±0.01d | 2.13±0.03c | 1.89±0.00d | 1.03±0.01e |
SDH | 2.39±0.00b | 2.33±0.01bc | 2.34±0.07b | 1.77±0.00c | ||
SSH | 2.55±0.00a | 2.52±0.03ab | 2.53±0.00a | 1.96±0.03a | ||
SSS | 2.53±0.01a | 2.66±0.15a | 2.48±0.00ab | 1.83±0.00b | ||
SH | 2.47±0.02ab | 2.30±0.05bc | 1.85±0.00d | 1.75±0.00c | ||
SRT | 2.28±0.06c | 2.15±0.03c | 1.84±0.07d | 1.07±0.01de | ||
SZT | 2.48±0.02a | 2.35±0.01bc | 2.17±0.02c | 1.11±0.02d | ||
收获期 | CK | 2.29±0.03d | 2.28±0.04e | 2.03±0.01e | 1.05±0.02d | |
SDH | 2.50±0.01c | 2.39±0.00d | 2.35±0.01c | 1.84±0.03b | ||
SSH | 2.90±0.01a | 2.55±0.01b | 2.58±0.03a | 1.97±0.01a | ||
SSS | 2.88±0.03a | 2.63±0.02a | 2.49±0.00b | 1.86±0.00b | ||
SH | 2.47±0.01c | 2.48±0.01bc | 2.18±0.01d | 1.78±0.01b | ||
SRT | 2.29±0.00d | 2.28±0.01e | 2.02±0.00e | 1.08±0.00d | ||
SZT | 2.78±0.02b | 2.48±0.01c | 2.37±0.00c | 1.52±0.06c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 2.11±0.02bc | 1.91±0.01c | 1.71±0.02b | 0.88±0.03c |
SDH | 2.24±0.05ab | 1.98±0.01bc | 1.74±0.02ab | 1.48±0.01a | ||
SSH | 2.33±0.05a | 2.10±0.05a | 1.82±0.05a | 1.57±0.01a | ||
SSS | 2.33±0.04a | 2.05±0.01b | 1.79±0.01ab | 1.54±0.03a | ||
SH | 2.25±0.02ab | 1.99±0.04bc | 1.75±0.01ab | 1.54±0.01a | ||
SRT | 2.06±0.05c | 1.98±0.06bc | 1.74±0.03ab | 0.77±0.02d | ||
SZT | 2.28±0.04a | 1.97±0.03bc | 1.76±0.03ab | 1.24±0.02b | ||
收获期 | CK | 3.14±0.01e | 2.63±0.00d | 2.08±0.01e | 1.71±0.03c | |
SDH | 3.25±0.02d | 2.91±0.01c | 2.34±0.01d | 1.94±0.02b | ||
SSH | 3.46±0.03b | 3.08±0.01ab | 2.67±0.02a | 2.42±0.01a | ||
SSS | 3.57±0.02a | 3.12±0.03a | 2.72±0.03a | 2.07±0.02a | ||
SH | 3.35±0.02c | 3.05±0.00b | 2.43±0.01c | 1.88±0.05b | ||
SRT | 3.07±0.01e | 2.67±0.01d | 2.08±0.01e | 1.13±0.05d | ||
SZT | 3.49±0.00b | 2.95±0.01c | 2.54±0.02b | 1.89±0.03b | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 2.17±0.01d | 2.13±0.03c | 1.89±0.00d | 1.03±0.01e |
SDH | 2.39±0.00b | 2.33±0.01bc | 2.34±0.07b | 1.77±0.00c | ||
SSH | 2.55±0.00a | 2.52±0.03ab | 2.53±0.00a | 1.96±0.03a | ||
SSS | 2.53±0.01a | 2.66±0.15a | 2.48±0.00ab | 1.83±0.00b | ||
SH | 2.47±0.02ab | 2.30±0.05bc | 1.85±0.00d | 1.75±0.00c | ||
SRT | 2.28±0.06c | 2.15±0.03c | 1.84±0.07d | 1.07±0.01de | ||
SZT | 2.48±0.02a | 2.35±0.01bc | 2.17±0.02c | 1.11±0.02d | ||
收获期 | CK | 2.29±0.03d | 2.28±0.04e | 2.03±0.01e | 1.05±0.02d | |
SDH | 2.50±0.01c | 2.39±0.00d | 2.35±0.01c | 1.84±0.03b | ||
SSH | 2.90±0.01a | 2.55±0.01b | 2.58±0.03a | 1.97±0.01a | ||
SSS | 2.88±0.03a | 2.63±0.02a | 2.49±0.00b | 1.86±0.00b | ||
SH | 2.47±0.01c | 2.48±0.01bc | 2.18±0.01d | 1.78±0.01b | ||
SRT | 2.29±0.00d | 2.28±0.01e | 2.02±0.00e | 1.08±0.00d | ||
SZT | 2.78±0.02b | 2.48±0.01c | 2.37±0.00c | 1.52±0.06c |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 4.18±0.05c | 3.27±0.04b | 3.07±0.01b | 2.43±0.01b |
SDH | 4.63±0.02a | 3.62±0.06b | 3.34±0.04a | 2.75±0.01a | ||
SSH | 4.67±0.01a | 4.37±0.37a | 3.35±0.02a | 2.75±0.01a | ||
SSS | 4.64±0.12a | 3.67±0.03b | 3.39±0.06a | 2.78±0.03a | ||
SH | 4.46±0.01ab | 3.52±0.04b | 3.16±0.01b | 2.73±0.01b | ||
SRT | 4.20±0.01c | 3.30±0.00b | 3.12±0.01b | 2.48±0.01b | ||
SZT | 4.37±0.07bc | 3.36±0.04b | 3.13±0.04b | 2.67±0.04b | ||
收获期 | CK | 4.53±0.07d | 4.24±0.03c | 3.42±0.01b | 3.08±0.07c | |
SDH | 4.76±0.01bc | 4.54±0.02b | 3.72±0.05ab | 3.28±0.02b | ||
SSH | 5.96±0.08ab | 4.80±0.03a | 3.78±0.07a | 3.55±0.02a | ||
SSS | 4.84±0.03b | 4.59±0.01b | 3.77±0.08a | 3.29±0.01b | ||
SH | 4.63±0.05cd | 4.44±0.02b | 3.69±0.05ab | 3.22±0.00b | ||
SRT | 4.59±0.03cd | 4.22±0.14c | 3.47±0.01ab | 3.19±0.05bc | ||
SZT | 4.69±0.05cd | 4.43±0.01b | 3.51±0.14ab | 3.21±0.01b | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 2.52±0.11c | 2.43±0.14c | 2.85±0.08d | 2.27±0.02c |
SDH | 5.58±0.32a | 5.12±0.01ab | 3.65±0.02b | 3.20±0.06ab | ||
SSH | 6.08±0.29a | 6.01±0.09a | 4.47±0.01a | 3.47±0.09ab | ||
SSS | 5.62±0.01a | 5.13±0.02ab | 4.20±0.02a | 3.57±0.11a | ||
SH | 4.66±0.08b | 4.46±1.17b | 3.18±0.18c | 3.16±0.12b | ||
SRT | 2.80±0.04c | 2.66±0.15c | 2.43±0.09e | 2.25±0.16c | ||
SZT | 2.96±0.06c | 2.93±0.10c | 2.88±0.05d | 2.29±0.15c | ||
收获期 | CK | 4.61±0.10b | 4.29±0.12d | 3.10±0.09d | 2.91±0.13c | |
SDH | 5.63±0.20ab | 5.12±0.05b | 3.67±0.13bc | 3.35±0.24abc | ||
SSH | 6.82±0.88a | 6.38±0.08a | 4.58±0.10a | 3.56±0.15ab | ||
SSS | 5.65±0.08ab | 5.14±0.04b | 4.22±0.14a | 3.70±0.15a | ||
SH | 5.39±0.14b | 4.82±0.03bc | 3.51±0.15cd | 3.21±0.11abc | ||
SRT | 4.52±0.08b | 4.55±0.18cd | 3.14±0.25ab | 2.94±0.14c | ||
SZT | 5.26±0.09b | 4.79±0.15bc | 3.37±0.06cd | 3.06±0.13bc |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 4.18±0.05c | 3.27±0.04b | 3.07±0.01b | 2.43±0.01b |
SDH | 4.63±0.02a | 3.62±0.06b | 3.34±0.04a | 2.75±0.01a | ||
SSH | 4.67±0.01a | 4.37±0.37a | 3.35±0.02a | 2.75±0.01a | ||
SSS | 4.64±0.12a | 3.67±0.03b | 3.39±0.06a | 2.78±0.03a | ||
SH | 4.46±0.01ab | 3.52±0.04b | 3.16±0.01b | 2.73±0.01b | ||
SRT | 4.20±0.01c | 3.30±0.00b | 3.12±0.01b | 2.48±0.01b | ||
SZT | 4.37±0.07bc | 3.36±0.04b | 3.13±0.04b | 2.67±0.04b | ||
收获期 | CK | 4.53±0.07d | 4.24±0.03c | 3.42±0.01b | 3.08±0.07c | |
SDH | 4.76±0.01bc | 4.54±0.02b | 3.72±0.05ab | 3.28±0.02b | ||
SSH | 5.96±0.08ab | 4.80±0.03a | 3.78±0.07a | 3.55±0.02a | ||
SSS | 4.84±0.03b | 4.59±0.01b | 3.77±0.08a | 3.29±0.01b | ||
SH | 4.63±0.05cd | 4.44±0.02b | 3.69±0.05ab | 3.22±0.00b | ||
SRT | 4.59±0.03cd | 4.22±0.14c | 3.47±0.01ab | 3.19±0.05bc | ||
SZT | 4.69±0.05cd | 4.43±0.01b | 3.51±0.14ab | 3.21±0.01b | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 2.52±0.11c | 2.43±0.14c | 2.85±0.08d | 2.27±0.02c |
SDH | 5.58±0.32a | 5.12±0.01ab | 3.65±0.02b | 3.20±0.06ab | ||
SSH | 6.08±0.29a | 6.01±0.09a | 4.47±0.01a | 3.47±0.09ab | ||
SSS | 5.62±0.01a | 5.13±0.02ab | 4.20±0.02a | 3.57±0.11a | ||
SH | 4.66±0.08b | 4.46±1.17b | 3.18±0.18c | 3.16±0.12b | ||
SRT | 2.80±0.04c | 2.66±0.15c | 2.43±0.09e | 2.25±0.16c | ||
SZT | 2.96±0.06c | 2.93±0.10c | 2.88±0.05d | 2.29±0.15c | ||
收获期 | CK | 4.61±0.10b | 4.29±0.12d | 3.10±0.09d | 2.91±0.13c | |
SDH | 5.63±0.20ab | 5.12±0.05b | 3.67±0.13bc | 3.35±0.24abc | ||
SSH | 6.82±0.88a | 6.38±0.08a | 4.58±0.10a | 3.56±0.15ab | ||
SSS | 5.65±0.08ab | 5.14±0.04b | 4.22±0.14a | 3.70±0.15a | ||
SH | 5.39±0.14b | 4.82±0.03bc | 3.51±0.15cd | 3.21±0.11abc | ||
SRT | 4.52±0.08b | 4.55±0.18cd | 3.14±0.25ab | 2.94±0.14c | ||
SZT | 5.26±0.09b | 4.79±0.15bc | 3.37±0.06cd | 3.06±0.13bc |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 33.22±2.30b | 32.99±1.54c | 27.40±2.66b | 20.60±0.31b |
SDH | 44.76±1.76a | 42.54±1.64b | 37.09±0.66ab | 29.60±1.98a | ||
SSH | 45.25±1.77a | 45.68±2.41b | 45.98±1.15a | 31.46±2.72a | ||
SSS | 46.54±1.57a | 59.89±1.74a | 38.58±2.33ab | 30.02±1.51a | ||
SH | 44.36±2.38a | 41.88±0.48b | 34.90±1.82b | 28.93±1.44a | ||
SRT | 40.11±2.31ab | 31.63±0.88c | 30.90±1.98b | 25.34±1.76ab | ||
SZT | 42.16±2.97ab | 41.86±1.85b | 34.81±2.51b | 28.80±1.33a | ||
收获期 | CK | 32.27±0.93c | 30.64±0.91b | 25.95±0.05c | 24.36±2.38d | |
SDH | 37.61±1.82ab | 34.62±1.16ab | 31.76±0.96b | 25.78±0.97bc | ||
SSH | 39.99±2.51ab | 34.67±1.20ab | 32.67±2.03ab | 30.00±1.53a | ||
SSS | 40.33±1.76a | 36.41±2.23a | 36.48±1.62a | 29.33±1.33ab | ||
SH | 36.90±0.49abc | 33.21±2.90ab | 31.45±0.29b | 25.71±2.16bc | ||
SRT | 35.23±0.40bc | 31.29±0.29ab | 30.20±0.70bc | 25.51±1.25cd | ||
SZT | 35.75±0.38abc | 32.68±0.66ab | 31.26±1.75b | 27.13±1.62abc | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 47.26±1.50c | 50.33±0.36c | 50.80±1.84d | 53.33±0.89de |
SDH | 52.85±0.75abc | 54.43±0.70b | 55.37±0.08b | 55.93±0.44bc | ||
SSH | 57.50±0.28ab | 60.42±1.57a | 56.00±0.36b | 60.10±0.34a | ||
SSS | 59.00±1.97a | 60.26±0.59a | 61.91±0.27a | 57.58±0.48b | ||
SH | 56.32±0.52ab | 54.27±0.28b | 54.98±0.28b | 55.22±0.44c | ||
SRT | 51.83±0.21bc | 52.54±0.62bc | 52.30±0.08cd | 51.75±0.55e | ||
SZT | 52.62±0.55abc | 53.33±0.69b | 53.64±0.55bc | 54.19±0.16cd |
年份 | 时期 | 处理 | 0~10 cm | 10~20 cm | 20~40 cm | 40~60 cm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2018年 | 播种前 | CK | 33.22±2.30b | 32.99±1.54c | 27.40±2.66b | 20.60±0.31b |
SDH | 44.76±1.76a | 42.54±1.64b | 37.09±0.66ab | 29.60±1.98a | ||
SSH | 45.25±1.77a | 45.68±2.41b | 45.98±1.15a | 31.46±2.72a | ||
SSS | 46.54±1.57a | 59.89±1.74a | 38.58±2.33ab | 30.02±1.51a | ||
SH | 44.36±2.38a | 41.88±0.48b | 34.90±1.82b | 28.93±1.44a | ||
SRT | 40.11±2.31ab | 31.63±0.88c | 30.90±1.98b | 25.34±1.76ab | ||
SZT | 42.16±2.97ab | 41.86±1.85b | 34.81±2.51b | 28.80±1.33a | ||
收获期 | CK | 32.27±0.93c | 30.64±0.91b | 25.95±0.05c | 24.36±2.38d | |
SDH | 37.61±1.82ab | 34.62±1.16ab | 31.76±0.96b | 25.78±0.97bc | ||
SSH | 39.99±2.51ab | 34.67±1.20ab | 32.67±2.03ab | 30.00±1.53a | ||
SSS | 40.33±1.76a | 36.41±2.23a | 36.48±1.62a | 29.33±1.33ab | ||
SH | 36.90±0.49abc | 33.21±2.90ab | 31.45±0.29b | 25.71±2.16bc | ||
SRT | 35.23±0.40bc | 31.29±0.29ab | 30.20±0.70bc | 25.51±1.25cd | ||
SZT | 35.75±0.38abc | 32.68±0.66ab | 31.26±1.75b | 27.13±1.62abc | ||
2019年 | 播种前 | CK | 47.26±1.50c | 50.33±0.36c | 50.80±1.84d | 53.33±0.89de |
SDH | 52.85±0.75abc | 54.43±0.70b | 55.37±0.08b | 55.93±0.44bc | ||
SSH | 57.50±0.28ab | 60.42±1.57a | 56.00±0.36b | 60.10±0.34a | ||
SSS | 59.00±1.97a | 60.26±0.59a | 61.91±0.27a | 57.58±0.48b | ||
SH | 56.32±0.52ab | 54.27±0.28b | 54.98±0.28b | 55.22±0.44c | ||
SRT | 51.83±0.21bc | 52.54±0.62bc | 52.30±0.08cd | 51.75±0.55e | ||
SZT | 52.62±0.55abc | 53.33±0.69b | 53.64±0.55bc | 54.19±0.16cd |
[1] | 陈帅. 黑土区坡耕地玉米秸秆还田水土保持功效研究[D]. 北京: 中国科学院大学, 2019. |
[2] | 刘玮斌. 不同秸秆还田方式对土壤酶和速效养分的影响[D]. 长春: 吉林农业大学, 2019. |
[3] | 康国平. 秸秆还田研究进展[J]. 现代农业, 2018(1):53-54. |
[4] | 韩上, 武际, 李敏, 等. 深耕结合秸秆还田提高作物产量并改善耕层薄化土壤理化性质[J]. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2020(2):276-284. |
[5] | 王小雷. 玉米秸秆还田和不同耕作方式对冬小麦影响的生理生态效应[D]. 合肥: 安徽农业大学, 2011. |
[6] | 陈丽, 马贤超, 田宝庚, 等. 耕作方式与秸秆还田对土壤肥力的影响[J]. 安徽农业科学, 2019(10):64-66. |
[7] | 何鑫. 不同耕作方式对农田黑土理化性质及玉米叶片PSⅡ功能的影响[D]. 哈尔滨: 东北农业大学, 2017. |
[8] | 孙庭炜. 不同耕作方式对黑土理化性质及玉米产量的影响[J]. 吉林农业大学学报, 2020(4):421-426. |
[9] | 王晶, 张仁陟, 李爱宗. 耕作方式对土壤活性有机碳和碳库管理指数的影响[J]. 干旱地区农业研究, 2008(6):8-12. |
[10] | 田慎重, 张玉凤, 边文范, 等. 深松和秸秆还田对旋耕农田土壤有机碳活性组分的影响[J]. 农业工程学报, 2020, 36(2):185-92. |
[11] | 庄恒扬, 刘世平, 沈新平, 等. 长期少免耕对稻麦产量及土壤有机质与容重的影响[J]. 中国农业科学, 1999(4):41-46. |
[12] | 张志猛, 戴良香, 张电学, 等. 冬小麦夏玉米轮作周期内碱解氮、硝态氮时空变化及施氮安全值的研究[J]. 土壤通报, 2004(1):38-42. |
[13] | 郭伟, 陈红霞, 张庆忠, 等. 华北高产农田施用生物质炭对耕层土壤总氮和碱解氮含量的影响[J]. 生态环境学报, 2011, 20(3):425-428. |
[14] | 祝滔, 郝庆菊, 江长胜, 等. 耕作方式对西南地区紫色水稻土全氮及碱解氮的影响[J]. 地理科学, 2011(6):753-757. |
[15] | 张四伟. 不同耕作方式与秸秆还田方式对稻麦轮作农田土壤养分及碳库的影响[D]. 南京: 南京农业大学, 2012. |
[16] | 吴安军, 郑华斌, 陈立军, 等. 不同耕作方式与覆盖物对稻田土壤养分的影响[J]. 湖南农业科学, 2011(15):29-32. |
[17] |
王新兵, 侯海鹏, 周宝元, 等. 条带深松对不同密度玉米群体根系空间分布的调节效应[J]. 作物学报, 2014, 40(12):2136-2148.
doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1006.2014.02136 |
[18] | 杨静, 聂三安, 杨文浩, 陈成榕, 等. 不同施肥水稻土可溶性有机氮组分差异及影响因素[J]. 土壤学报, 2018, 55(4):955-966. |
[19] | MATTHEWS A M, ARMSTRONG A C, LEEDS-HARRISON P B, et al. Development and testing of a model for predicting tillage effects on nitrate leaching from cracked clay soils[J]. Soil & tillage research, 2000, 53(3-4):245-254. |
[20] | ASHLEY M K, GRANT M, GRABOV A. Plant responses to potassium deficiencies: a role for potassium transport proteins[J]. Journal of experimental botany, 2006, 57(2). |
[21] | 韩玉玲. 玉稻轮作下秸秆全量还田对土壤培肥及钾肥减施效应的研究[D]. 武汉: 华中农业大学, 2020. |
[22] | 赵红香. 秸秆还田与耕作方式对麦—玉两熟农田土壤质量和生产力的影响[D]. 泰安: 山东农业大学, 2013. |
[23] | 杨滨娟, 黄国勤, 徐宁, 等. 秸秆还田配施不同比例化肥对晚稻产量及土壤养分的影响[J]. 生态学报, 2014, 34(13):3779-3787. |
[24] | 候贤请, 吴鹏年, 王艳丽, 等. 秸秆还田配施氮肥对土壤水肥状况和玉米产量的影响[J]. 应用生态学报, 2018, 29(6):1928-1934. |
[25] | 张春. 不同耕作方式对水稻土供钾能力的影响[D]. 重庆: 西南大学, 2015. |
[26] | 侯贤清. 宁南旱区保护性耕作技术对土壤性状及作物生长的影响[D]. 西安: 西北农林科技大学, 2009. |
[27] | 韩宾, 李增嘉, 王芸, 等. 土壤耕作及秸秆还田对冬小麦生长状况及产量的影响[J]. 农业工程学报, 2007(2):48-53. |
[1] | LI Xiaoyu. Cultivation and Product Analysis of Pleurotus eryngii on Phragmites australis Substrates [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2023, 39(1): 51-55. |
[2] | CUI Yingying, ZHOU Bo, CHEN Yiyong, LIU Jiayu, LI Jianlong, TANG Hao, TANG Jinchi. Spatial-temporal Variation Analysis and Comprehensive Evaluation of Soil Fertility in Guangdong Major Tea Areas [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2023, 39(1): 85-95. |
[3] | ZENG Jie, YU Lang, DABU Xilatu, LI Yunju. Effects of Phosphorus-based Soil Conditioner on Growth of Chinese Cabbage in Low-phosphorus Red Soil [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(9): 81-87. |
[4] | DONG Wencai, LIU Xianbin, LI Hongmei, ZHAO Shuangmei, BAO Jinmei, SHEN Jianping, LIANG Fang, LU Mei. Effects of Calcium Supply with Varying Levels on the Growth and Development of Woody Ornamental Plants [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(8): 42-50. |
[5] | HUANG Hao, XIE Jin, YUAN Wenbin, WANG Chuliang, CHEN Kunhua, ZENG Fandong, LIANG Zengfa, SU Zhao, WANG Wei. Effects of Different Organic Materials on Root Characteristics and Accumulation of Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Potassium in Flue-cured Tobacco [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(8): 51-57. |
[6] | QIN Naiqun, MA Qiaoyun, GAO Jingwei, YANG Pu, CAI Jinlan, HAO Yingchun, LI Yanmei, JI Hongce, LIAO Xiangzheng. Effects of Biogas Residue Application on Nutrient and Heavy Metal Content in Soil and Yield of Crops Under Peanut-wheat Rotation [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(8): 58-63. |
[7] | WANG Lina, YANG Ying, Du Su. Effects of Biochar Application on Saline-alkali Soil: Research Status [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(8): 81-87. |
[8] | CAO Qiumei, WANG Luyi, LI Xiaoman, LI Junda, LIU Mengtian, ZHENG Yao, WANG Lihua. Effects of Effective Microorganisms on Growth Performance, Nutrient Digestibility and Fecal Ammonia Emission of BALB/C Mice [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(7): 124-128. |
[9] | LI Dongxue, WANG Yiliu, HUAN Weiwei, BU Lingduo, WANG Ruizhi, LIU Hao, LU Dianjun, WANG Huoyan, CHEN Xiaoqin. Nutrient Content of Tobacco Leaves and Root Zone Soil Affected by Citrate Soluble Potassium Fertilizer in Yuxi [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(7): 67-73. |
[10] | CHEN Hui, ZHOU Xiaoyue, TAN Cheng, ZHANG Yongchun, WANG Jidong, MA Hongbo. Effects of Milk Vetch Returning to Field on the Content of Soil Nutrient and Heavy Metal [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(7): 80-85. |
[11] | ZHAO Yue, ZHANG Xiaoyan, CAO Kun, HAN Chengwei, JIANG Ying, BIAN Jing, WANG Xiaonan, SUN Yufeng. Physiology and Molecular Mechanism of Stress Resistance in Hemp: A Review [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(6): 102-106. |
[12] | HAN Xiaofang, TIAN Xiaoming, YANG Yongli, ZHANG Jingzhi, ZHANG Qing, ZHANG Kai, ZHANG Tao, JIA Lin. Two Soil Compound Amendments: Improvement and Fertility Effect on Coastal Saline Soil [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(5): 54-59. |
[13] | CHEN Zhi, CHEN Duhuang, QIN Zhiqing, XU Shan, ZHOU Minglong. Comparative Analysis of Nutrient Compositions in Different Tissues of Female Tri-Spine Horseshoe Crab Tachypleus tridentatus [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(4): 153-156. |
[14] | SUN Yiliang, LI Haiyan, MA Zhimin, WU Fangyu. Research Progress of Royal Jelly in Improving Human Immunity and Symptomatic Treatment of Perimenopausal Women [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(35): 119-124. |
[15] | GESANG Dunzhun. Soil Nutrient Status Analysis and Soil Fertility Comprehensive Evaluation in Luolong County of Changdu City in Tibet [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(35): 30-34. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||