Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin ›› 2020, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (10): 69-78.doi: 10.11924/j.issn.1000-6850.casb18120105
• Research article • Previous Articles Next Articles
Mi Qin1,2,3(), Fengluan Liu2,3, Qingqing Liu2,3, Jianguo Cao1, Yuchu Chen4, Daike Tian2,3(
)
Received:
2018-12-25
Revised:
2019-02-19
Online:
2020-04-05
Published:
2020-03-19
CLC Number:
Mi Qin, Fengluan Liu, Qingqing Liu, Jianguo Cao, Yuchu Chen, Daike Tian. Comparis on In Vitro Culture of Mature Embryos of Nelumbo from Eight Provenances Worldwide[J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2020, 36(10): 69-78.
Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX
URL: https://www.casb.org.cn/EN/10.11924/j.issn.1000-6850.casb18120105
编号 | 代表种源名 | 种名 | 原产地 | 生态型 | 株型 | 花色 | 瓣型 | 凭证标本/栽培号 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
中文名 | 拉丁文 | ||||||||
PLD | 普兰店古莲 | 亚洲莲 | Nelumbo nucifera | 中国辽宁大连普兰店区 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | M385 |
HLJ | 黑龙江莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 中国黑龙江挠力河 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | M474 |
BYD | 白洋淀红莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 中国河北新安县白洋淀 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | M282 |
WSH | 微山湖红莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 中国山东滕州市微山湖 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | TDK1036/M655 |
VN | 越南莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 越南海阳市 | 温带型 | 大型 | 粉色 | 单瓣 | TDK2914 |
TH | 泰国莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 泰国清迈Sarapee区11号公路旁 | 热带型 | 大型 | 白色 | 单瓣 | TDK2782/L140 |
IN | 印度莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 印度Maharashtra邦 | 温带型 | 大型 | 淡粉色 | 单瓣 | TDK1603/M469 |
AU | 澳大利亚莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 澳大利亚北部Mary River附近 | 热带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | L131 |
NLU | 美洲莲 | 美洲莲 | N. lutea | 美洲佛罗尼达迈阿密Okeechobee湖 | 温带型 | 大型 | 黄色 | 单瓣 | TDK642/M519 |
编号 | 代表种源名 | 种名 | 原产地 | 生态型 | 株型 | 花色 | 瓣型 | 凭证标本/栽培号 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
中文名 | 拉丁文 | ||||||||
PLD | 普兰店古莲 | 亚洲莲 | Nelumbo nucifera | 中国辽宁大连普兰店区 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | M385 |
HLJ | 黑龙江莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 中国黑龙江挠力河 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | M474 |
BYD | 白洋淀红莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 中国河北新安县白洋淀 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | M282 |
WSH | 微山湖红莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 中国山东滕州市微山湖 | 温带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | TDK1036/M655 |
VN | 越南莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 越南海阳市 | 温带型 | 大型 | 粉色 | 单瓣 | TDK2914 |
TH | 泰国莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 泰国清迈Sarapee区11号公路旁 | 热带型 | 大型 | 白色 | 单瓣 | TDK2782/L140 |
IN | 印度莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 印度Maharashtra邦 | 温带型 | 大型 | 淡粉色 | 单瓣 | TDK1603/M469 |
AU | 澳大利亚莲 | 亚洲莲 | N. nucifera | 澳大利亚北部Mary River附近 | 热带型 | 大型 | 红色 | 单瓣 | L131 |
NLU | 美洲莲 | 美洲莲 | N. lutea | 美洲佛罗尼达迈阿密Okeechobee湖 | 温带型 | 大型 | 黄色 | 单瓣 | TDK642/M519 |
方法 | 短时消毒步骤 | 长时催芽步骤 | 莲胚无菌率/% | 10 d莲胚正常生长率/% |
---|---|---|---|---|
处理1 | 2% PPM × 2 h | 0.01% PPM × 5 d | 90 | 85 |
处理2 | 2% PPM × 2 h | 0.05% PPM × 5 d | 100 | 95 |
处理3 | 2% PPM × 2 h | 0.1% PPM × 5 d | 100 | 75 |
CK1 | 2% NaClO × 5 min | 无菌水× 5 d | 75 | 25 |
CK2 | 2% NaClO × 10 min | 无菌水× 5 d | 90 | 20 |
方法 | 短时消毒步骤 | 长时催芽步骤 | 莲胚无菌率/% | 10 d莲胚正常生长率/% |
---|---|---|---|---|
处理1 | 2% PPM × 2 h | 0.01% PPM × 5 d | 90 | 85 |
处理2 | 2% PPM × 2 h | 0.05% PPM × 5 d | 100 | 95 |
处理3 | 2% PPM × 2 h | 0.1% PPM × 5 d | 100 | 75 |
CK1 | 2% NaClO × 5 min | 无菌水× 5 d | 75 | 25 |
CK2 | 2% NaClO × 10 min | 无菌水× 5 d | 90 | 20 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 长小于1 cm根数 | 长大于1 cm根数 | 总根数 | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | ||||||
PLD | 1.8±0.53a | 2.0±0.00a | 10.2±1.74ab | 7.5±2.60a | 56.6±18.51a | 39.6±12.91ab | 2.8±1.32a | 5.0±1.23a | 0.8±0.58bc | 9.4±1.97a | 3.6±1.57ab | 14.4±2.32a | |||||
HLJ | 2.2±0.17a | 3.0±0.00a | 12.0±0.45a | 9.6±1.04a | 14.5±1.92b | 30.7±4.44ab | 1.8±1.05a | 5.0±0.86a | 0.2±0.17c | 5.7±0.56ab | 2.0±1.83ab | 10.7±1.09ab | |||||
BYD | 1.8±0.25a | 3.0±0.00a | 12.0±0.41a | 13.1±3.37a | 32.8±12.18ab | 44.8±14.96ab | 1.0±0.71a | 5.3±1.44a | 4.0±1.41a | 5.3±1.11ab | 5.0±1.68a | 10.5±0.87ab | |||||
WSH | 1.8±0.20a | 2.4±0.40a | 8.6±1.29ab | 9.1±0.97a | 21.0±9.80b | 31.7±8.10ab | 2.6±0.87a | 5.4±0.51a | 0.2±0.20c | 4.0±1.41ab | 2.8±0.86ab | 9.4±1.12ab | |||||
VN | 1.0±0.32a | 3.0±0.26a | 9.0±1.08ab | 9.1±0.99a | 33.5±10.49ab | 44.1±6.94ab | 0.5±0.50a | 2.8±1.40a | 0.0±0.00c | 2.8±0.79b | 0.5±0.50b | 4.6±2.32b | |||||
TH | 1.3±0.75a | 2.8±0.48a | 11.0±1.58ab | 5.8±3.38a | 44.8±7.04ab | 20.9±12.49b | 1.0±0.58a | 5.5±1.93a | 2.5±1.50ab | 6.5±2.22ab | 3.5±2.06ab | 12.0±4.14ab | |||||
IN | 2.0±0.26a | 2.2±0.49a | 10.5±1.47ab | 9.5±3.50a | 48.2±8.87ab | 70.3±53.25a | 0.3±0.33a | 3.3±1.65a | 0.0±0.00c | 5.3±3.09ab | 0.3±0.33b | 8.5±4.74ab | |||||
NLU | 1.3±0.48a | 2.4±0.40a | 7.0±0.41b | 6.7±2.38a | 26.8±7.95ab | 28.3±13.30ab | 0.5±0.50a | 2.5±1.66a | 0.8±0.75bc | 4.0±2.16ab | 1.3±1.25ab | 6.5±3.66ab | |||||
编号 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 | ||||||||||||
5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | ||||||||
PLD | 1.0±0.00a | 2.0±0.00a | 13.2±0.86a | 6.2±0.53ab | 2.2±0.20d | 2.8±0.39a | 0.62 | 0.75 | 1 | 2 | |||||||
HLJ | 1.0±0.01a | 1.0±0.00c | 9.0±1.21a | 5.9±0.64ab | 3.1±0.07ab | 2.9±0.20a | 0.43 | 0.11 | 4 | 8 | |||||||
BYD | 1.0±0.02a | 1.0±0.00c | 12.0±0.00a | 6.9±0.77a | 3.0±0.00abc | 3.0±0.20a | 0.6 | 0.75 | 2 | 1 | |||||||
WSH | 1.0±0.03a | 1.0±0.00c | 9.8±1.50a | 6.4±0.46ab | 2.4±0.40bcd | 3.1±0.11a | 0.27 | 0.6 | 6 | 4 | |||||||
VN | 1.0±0.04a | 1.2±0.17bc | 9.3±1.93a | 4.6±0.38b | 2.5±0.29bcd | 2.8±0.25a | 0.16 | 0.55 | 8 | 5 | |||||||
TH | 1.0±0.05a | 1.0±0.00c | 9.3±1.11a | 4.6±0.41b | 3.4±0.20a | 3.1±0.15a | 0.55 | 0.61 | 3 | 3 | |||||||
IN | 1.0±0.06a | 1.0±0.00c | 10.2±1.01a | 5.2±0.81ab | 2.7±0.21bcd | 2.1±0.78a | 0.33 | 0.54 | 5 | 6 | |||||||
NLU | 1.0±0.07a | 1.4±0.26ab | 9.0±1.58a | 5.6±0.58ab | 2.3±0.25cd | 2.9±0.30a | 0.22 | 0.51 | 7 | 7 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 长小于1 cm根数 | 长大于1 cm根数 | 总根数 | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | ||||||
PLD | 1.8±0.53a | 2.0±0.00a | 10.2±1.74ab | 7.5±2.60a | 56.6±18.51a | 39.6±12.91ab | 2.8±1.32a | 5.0±1.23a | 0.8±0.58bc | 9.4±1.97a | 3.6±1.57ab | 14.4±2.32a | |||||
HLJ | 2.2±0.17a | 3.0±0.00a | 12.0±0.45a | 9.6±1.04a | 14.5±1.92b | 30.7±4.44ab | 1.8±1.05a | 5.0±0.86a | 0.2±0.17c | 5.7±0.56ab | 2.0±1.83ab | 10.7±1.09ab | |||||
BYD | 1.8±0.25a | 3.0±0.00a | 12.0±0.41a | 13.1±3.37a | 32.8±12.18ab | 44.8±14.96ab | 1.0±0.71a | 5.3±1.44a | 4.0±1.41a | 5.3±1.11ab | 5.0±1.68a | 10.5±0.87ab | |||||
WSH | 1.8±0.20a | 2.4±0.40a | 8.6±1.29ab | 9.1±0.97a | 21.0±9.80b | 31.7±8.10ab | 2.6±0.87a | 5.4±0.51a | 0.2±0.20c | 4.0±1.41ab | 2.8±0.86ab | 9.4±1.12ab | |||||
VN | 1.0±0.32a | 3.0±0.26a | 9.0±1.08ab | 9.1±0.99a | 33.5±10.49ab | 44.1±6.94ab | 0.5±0.50a | 2.8±1.40a | 0.0±0.00c | 2.8±0.79b | 0.5±0.50b | 4.6±2.32b | |||||
TH | 1.3±0.75a | 2.8±0.48a | 11.0±1.58ab | 5.8±3.38a | 44.8±7.04ab | 20.9±12.49b | 1.0±0.58a | 5.5±1.93a | 2.5±1.50ab | 6.5±2.22ab | 3.5±2.06ab | 12.0±4.14ab | |||||
IN | 2.0±0.26a | 2.2±0.49a | 10.5±1.47ab | 9.5±3.50a | 48.2±8.87ab | 70.3±53.25a | 0.3±0.33a | 3.3±1.65a | 0.0±0.00c | 5.3±3.09ab | 0.3±0.33b | 8.5±4.74ab | |||||
NLU | 1.3±0.48a | 2.4±0.40a | 7.0±0.41b | 6.7±2.38a | 26.8±7.95ab | 28.3±13.30ab | 0.5±0.50a | 2.5±1.66a | 0.8±0.75bc | 4.0±2.16ab | 1.3±1.25ab | 6.5±3.66ab | |||||
编号 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 | ||||||||||||
5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | 5 d | 10 d | ||||||||
PLD | 1.0±0.00a | 2.0±0.00a | 13.2±0.86a | 6.2±0.53ab | 2.2±0.20d | 2.8±0.39a | 0.62 | 0.75 | 1 | 2 | |||||||
HLJ | 1.0±0.01a | 1.0±0.00c | 9.0±1.21a | 5.9±0.64ab | 3.1±0.07ab | 2.9±0.20a | 0.43 | 0.11 | 4 | 8 | |||||||
BYD | 1.0±0.02a | 1.0±0.00c | 12.0±0.00a | 6.9±0.77a | 3.0±0.00abc | 3.0±0.20a | 0.6 | 0.75 | 2 | 1 | |||||||
WSH | 1.0±0.03a | 1.0±0.00c | 9.8±1.50a | 6.4±0.46ab | 2.4±0.40bcd | 3.1±0.11a | 0.27 | 0.6 | 6 | 4 | |||||||
VN | 1.0±0.04a | 1.2±0.17bc | 9.3±1.93a | 4.6±0.38b | 2.5±0.29bcd | 2.8±0.25a | 0.16 | 0.55 | 8 | 5 | |||||||
TH | 1.0±0.05a | 1.0±0.00c | 9.3±1.11a | 4.6±0.41b | 3.4±0.20a | 3.1±0.15a | 0.55 | 0.61 | 3 | 3 | |||||||
IN | 1.0±0.06a | 1.0±0.00c | 10.2±1.01a | 5.2±0.81ab | 2.7±0.21bcd | 2.1±0.78a | 0.33 | 0.54 | 5 | 6 | |||||||
NLU | 1.0±0.07a | 1.4±0.26ab | 9.0±1.58a | 5.6±0.58ab | 2.3±0.25cd | 2.9±0.30a | 0.22 | 0.51 | 7 | 7 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 叶柄粗/mm | 长不大于 0.5 cm根数 | 长0.5~1 cm根数 | 长大于1 cm根数 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PLD | 2.3±0.85a | 12.5±0.50ab | 58.2±3.38a | 1.7±0.15a | 5.7±1.76ab | 7.3±2.03a | 4.7±4.00abc |
HLJ | 3.5±0.22a | 13.8±0.94ab | 123.0±9.39a | 1.4±0.08a | 3.5±0.56b | 1.8±0.60b | 6.5±1.43abc |
BYD | 3.8±0.25a | 12.5±1.55ab | 54.1±10.56a | 1.4±0.07a | 5.3±0.63ab | 2.3±1.03b | 5.5±0.50abc |
WSH | 2.4±0.68a | 13.6±1.57ab | 58.3±8.26a | 1.4±0.28a | 9.3±3.38a | 1.3±0.95b | 2.8±0.94bc |
VN | 3.1±0.33a | 15.2±2.61ab | 99.8±4.19a | 1.5±0.08a | 3.3±1.20b | 2.2±0.65b | 6.0±2.27abc |
TH | 2.8±1.25a | 17.7±0.33a | 80.4±5.23a | 1.5±0.13a | 4.0±1.00ab | 0.0±0.00b | 11.0±3.00a |
IN | 2.4±0.51a | 12.5±2.93ab | 136.8±8.07a | 1.2±0.16a | 1.3±0.33a | 3.3±1.86b | 9.3±2.73ab |
NLU | 2.7±0.33a | 8.5±1.00b | 25.7±5.65a | 1.2±0.22a | 7.0±2.00ab | 0.0±0.00b | 2.0±0.00c |
编号 | 总根数 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 | |
PLD | 17.7±1.45a | 2.0±0.00ab | 4.3±0.88ab | 2.9±0.07ab | 0.52 | 4 | |
HLJ | 11.8±1.28a | 2.0±0.00ab | 7.2±0.67a | 3.1±0.17ab | 0.55 | 2 | |
BYD | 13.0±0.71a | 2.0±0.00ab | 6.6±0.59ab | 3.6±0.10a | 0.56 | 1 | |
WSH | 13.3±4.59a | 2.0±0.00ab | 4.1±0.72b | 2.7±0.17b | 0.38 | 6 | |
VN | 11.5±3.06a | 2.5±0.22a | 6.7±0.73ab | 2.9±0.22ab | 0.55 | 3 | |
TH | 11.5±0.50a | 2.0±1.00ab | 5.8±1.17ab | 2.8±0.15b | 0.52 | 5 | |
IN | 14.0±4.04a | 1.0±0.45b | 6.7±1.17ab | 2.9±0.32ab | 0.35 | 7 | |
NLU | 9.0±2.00a | 1.5±0.50ab | 5.8±1.01ab | 3.1±0.22ab | 0.21 | 8 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 叶柄粗/mm | 长不大于 0.5 cm根数 | 长0.5~1 cm根数 | 长大于1 cm根数 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PLD | 2.3±0.85a | 12.5±0.50ab | 58.2±3.38a | 1.7±0.15a | 5.7±1.76ab | 7.3±2.03a | 4.7±4.00abc |
HLJ | 3.5±0.22a | 13.8±0.94ab | 123.0±9.39a | 1.4±0.08a | 3.5±0.56b | 1.8±0.60b | 6.5±1.43abc |
BYD | 3.8±0.25a | 12.5±1.55ab | 54.1±10.56a | 1.4±0.07a | 5.3±0.63ab | 2.3±1.03b | 5.5±0.50abc |
WSH | 2.4±0.68a | 13.6±1.57ab | 58.3±8.26a | 1.4±0.28a | 9.3±3.38a | 1.3±0.95b | 2.8±0.94bc |
VN | 3.1±0.33a | 15.2±2.61ab | 99.8±4.19a | 1.5±0.08a | 3.3±1.20b | 2.2±0.65b | 6.0±2.27abc |
TH | 2.8±1.25a | 17.7±0.33a | 80.4±5.23a | 1.5±0.13a | 4.0±1.00ab | 0.0±0.00b | 11.0±3.00a |
IN | 2.4±0.51a | 12.5±2.93ab | 136.8±8.07a | 1.2±0.16a | 1.3±0.33a | 3.3±1.86b | 9.3±2.73ab |
NLU | 2.7±0.33a | 8.5±1.00b | 25.7±5.65a | 1.2±0.22a | 7.0±2.00ab | 0.0±0.00b | 2.0±0.00c |
编号 | 总根数 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 | |
PLD | 17.7±1.45a | 2.0±0.00ab | 4.3±0.88ab | 2.9±0.07ab | 0.52 | 4 | |
HLJ | 11.8±1.28a | 2.0±0.00ab | 7.2±0.67a | 3.1±0.17ab | 0.55 | 2 | |
BYD | 13.0±0.71a | 2.0±0.00ab | 6.6±0.59ab | 3.6±0.10a | 0.56 | 1 | |
WSH | 13.3±4.59a | 2.0±0.00ab | 4.1±0.72b | 2.7±0.17b | 0.38 | 6 | |
VN | 11.5±3.06a | 2.5±0.22a | 6.7±0.73ab | 2.9±0.22ab | 0.55 | 3 | |
TH | 11.5±0.50a | 2.0±1.00ab | 5.8±1.17ab | 2.8±0.15b | 0.52 | 5 | |
IN | 14.0±4.04a | 1.0±0.45b | 6.7±1.17ab | 2.9±0.32ab | 0.35 | 7 | |
NLU | 9.0±2.00a | 1.5±0.50ab | 5.8±1.01ab | 3.1±0.22ab | 0.21 | 8 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶长径/mm | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 叶柄粗/mm | 长不大于0.5 cm根数 | 长0.5~1 cm根数 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PLD | 5.0±1.53ab | 22.6±10.21ab | 18.4±9.05abc | 206.4±16.08ab | 1.2±0.30a | 4.4±1.63a | 2.8±0.17b |
HLJ | 4.3±0.21ab | 29.6±1.36ab | 26.4±1.39ab | 300.4±15.66a | 1.2±0.04a | 2.1±0.58ab | 1.8±0.36bcd |
BYD | 1.5±0.65c | 24.1±9.52ab | 21.6±9.43abc | 128.2±40.33c | 1.4±0.10a | 0.5±0.05b | 7.2±0.41a |
WSH | 2.8±0.86bc | 19.1±4.84ab | 11.3±6.70bc | 101.1±26.81c | 1.1±0.03a | 2.0±1.41ab | 0.79±0.09cd |
VN | 6.0±0.82a | 28.9±1.39ab | 27.5±1.83ab | 196.2±12.75ab | 1.2±0.06a | 3.3±0.67ab | 2.1±0.11bc |
TH | 6.0±0.82a | 33.5±1.06a | 30.3±0.94a | 282.9±19.41a | 1.1±0.04a | 2.8±0.84ab | 2.0±0.02bc |
IN | 4.0±0.41abc | 26.7±1.75ab | 21.9±2.10abc | 201.8±33.84ab | 1.3±0.15a | 1.3±0.75ab | 0.5±0.01cd |
NLU | 3.5±0.50abc | 18.6±2.89ab | 7.8±7.75c | 115.8±48.23c | 1.1±0.28a | 1.5±0.05ab | 0.0±0.00d |
编号 | 长大于1 cm根数 | 总根数 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 |
PLD | 5.4±2.68ab | 12.6±0.14a | 3.3±0.33b | 5.7±1.20a | 3.2±0.16a | 0.58 | 3 |
HLJ | 6.9±0.82a | 10.5±0.33a | 3.0±0.00bc | 6.1±0.96a | 2.4±0.18ab | 0.56 | 4 |
BYD | 1.0±0.05b | 8.7±0.88ab | 1.5±0.50c | 9.4±3.38a | 2.9±1.14ab | 0.40 | 6 |
WSH | 4.2±0.81ab | 7.0±0.38ab | 2.4±0.25bc | 7.2±1.66a | 1.7±0.18ab | 0.22 | 7 |
VN | 7.6±0.56a | 13.1±0.95a | 5.2±0.87a | 11.1±0.84a | 1.6±0.23b | 0.62 | 2 |
TH | 7.2±1.45a | 12.0±0.28a | 5.0±0.41a | 7.8±1.51a | 1.7±0.17ab | 0.68 | 1 |
IN | 8.8±0.84a | 10.6±0.76a | 2.5±0.29bc | 5.6±0.62a | 2.1±0.16ab | 0.54 | 5 |
NLU | 1.5±0.05b | 3.00±0.10b | 3.0±0.00bc | 5.9±0.68a | 3.0±0.35ab | 0.22 | 8 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶长径/mm | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 叶柄粗/mm | 长不大于0.5 cm根数 | 长0.5~1 cm根数 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PLD | 5.0±1.53ab | 22.6±10.21ab | 18.4±9.05abc | 206.4±16.08ab | 1.2±0.30a | 4.4±1.63a | 2.8±0.17b |
HLJ | 4.3±0.21ab | 29.6±1.36ab | 26.4±1.39ab | 300.4±15.66a | 1.2±0.04a | 2.1±0.58ab | 1.8±0.36bcd |
BYD | 1.5±0.65c | 24.1±9.52ab | 21.6±9.43abc | 128.2±40.33c | 1.4±0.10a | 0.5±0.05b | 7.2±0.41a |
WSH | 2.8±0.86bc | 19.1±4.84ab | 11.3±6.70bc | 101.1±26.81c | 1.1±0.03a | 2.0±1.41ab | 0.79±0.09cd |
VN | 6.0±0.82a | 28.9±1.39ab | 27.5±1.83ab | 196.2±12.75ab | 1.2±0.06a | 3.3±0.67ab | 2.1±0.11bc |
TH | 6.0±0.82a | 33.5±1.06a | 30.3±0.94a | 282.9±19.41a | 1.1±0.04a | 2.8±0.84ab | 2.0±0.02bc |
IN | 4.0±0.41abc | 26.7±1.75ab | 21.9±2.10abc | 201.8±33.84ab | 1.3±0.15a | 1.3±0.75ab | 0.5±0.01cd |
NLU | 3.5±0.50abc | 18.6±2.89ab | 7.8±7.75c | 115.8±48.23c | 1.1±0.28a | 1.5±0.05ab | 0.0±0.00d |
编号 | 长大于1 cm根数 | 总根数 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 |
PLD | 5.4±2.68ab | 12.6±0.14a | 3.3±0.33b | 5.7±1.20a | 3.2±0.16a | 0.58 | 3 |
HLJ | 6.9±0.82a | 10.5±0.33a | 3.0±0.00bc | 6.1±0.96a | 2.4±0.18ab | 0.56 | 4 |
BYD | 1.0±0.05b | 8.7±0.88ab | 1.5±0.50c | 9.4±3.38a | 2.9±1.14ab | 0.40 | 6 |
WSH | 4.2±0.81ab | 7.0±0.38ab | 2.4±0.25bc | 7.2±1.66a | 1.7±0.18ab | 0.22 | 7 |
VN | 7.6±0.56a | 13.1±0.95a | 5.2±0.87a | 11.1±0.84a | 1.6±0.23b | 0.62 | 2 |
TH | 7.2±1.45a | 12.0±0.28a | 5.0±0.41a | 7.8±1.51a | 1.7±0.17ab | 0.68 | 1 |
IN | 8.8±0.84a | 10.6±0.76a | 2.5±0.29bc | 5.6±0.62a | 2.1±0.16ab | 0.54 | 5 |
NLU | 1.5±0.05b | 3.00±0.10b | 3.0±0.00bc | 5.9±0.68a | 3.0±0.35ab | 0.22 | 8 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶展开数 | 叶长径/mm | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 叶柄粗/mm | 总根数 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PLD | 18.7±2.03a | 5.7±1.56b | 31.5±2.22b | 25.8±1.70b | 294.4±23.86cde | 0.8±0.10b | 139.3±15.68a |
HLJ | 10.8±1.11a | 5.5±0.65b | 40.0±3.93ab | 36.1±3.43ab | 326.7±27.78bcd | 1.4±0.08a | 152.3±2.24a |
BYD | 19.5±5.50a | 3.0±1.00b | 44.0±3.21a | 38.7±3.84a | 386.8±43.25ab | 1.1±0.05ab | 92.5±12.5a |
WSH | 21.8±2.29a | 3.0±0.71b | 43.8±3.22a | 37.4±3.59ab | 374.9±39.28abc | 1.4±0.10a | 118.0±4.94a |
VN | 32.1±2.70a | 11.4±0.84a | 38.6±2.24ab | 33.1±2.75ab | 274.4±16.21de | 1.2±0.08a | 218.0±5.24a |
TH | 24.9±9.13a | 12.0±2.11a | 40.8±2.41ab | 38.8±2.43a | 230.0±12.35e | 1.3±0.11a | 176.1±2.84a |
IN | 11.5±0.50a | 4.5±0.50b | 41.5±2.68ab | 36.0±3.15ab | 340.5±30.83bcd | 1.3±0.03a | 99.0±5.00a |
NLU | 11.7±1.67a | 1.3±0.33b | 46.5±2.50a | 34.5±2.50ab | 454.3±25.65a | 1.3±0.05a | 107.0±9.86a |
编号 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 芽数 | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 | |
PLD | 12.0±2.52a | 2.8±0.14c | 2.2±0.19b | 3.7±0.88b | 0.23 | 8 | |
HLJ | 8.8±1.44a | 10.7±2.10b | 3.0±0.19a | 2.0±0.00b | 0.46 | 4 | |
BYD | 7.5±0.50a | 4.1±0.50c | 2.3±0.15b | 3.5±0.50b | 0.40 | 6 | |
WSH | 13.5±1.56a | 11.7±1.77b | 2.4±0.13b | 4.5±1.60ab | 0.53 | 3 | |
VN | 18.4±1.51a | 13.7±1.59b | 1.6±0.13c | 10.6±1.95a | 0.65 | 1 | |
TH | 21.7±9.33a | 9.8±1.16b | 1.4±0.10c | 5.6±1.51ab | 0.58 | 2 | |
IN | 8.0±0.00a | 10.9±1.69b | 2.3±0.35b | 2.0±0.00b | 0.37 | 7 | |
NLU | 7.0±0.57a | 34.6±2.81a | 1.5±0.13c | 1.3±0.33b | 0.42 | 5 |
编号 | 叶数 | 叶展开数 | 叶长径/mm | 叶短径/mm | 叶柄长/mm | 叶柄粗/mm | 总根数 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PLD | 18.7±2.03a | 5.7±1.56b | 31.5±2.22b | 25.8±1.70b | 294.4±23.86cde | 0.8±0.10b | 139.3±15.68a |
HLJ | 10.8±1.11a | 5.5±0.65b | 40.0±3.93ab | 36.1±3.43ab | 326.7±27.78bcd | 1.4±0.08a | 152.3±2.24a |
BYD | 19.5±5.50a | 3.0±1.00b | 44.0±3.21a | 38.7±3.84a | 386.8±43.25ab | 1.1±0.05ab | 92.5±12.5a |
WSH | 21.8±2.29a | 3.0±0.71b | 43.8±3.22a | 37.4±3.59ab | 374.9±39.28abc | 1.4±0.10a | 118.0±4.94a |
VN | 32.1±2.70a | 11.4±0.84a | 38.6±2.24ab | 33.1±2.75ab | 274.4±16.21de | 1.2±0.08a | 218.0±5.24a |
TH | 24.9±9.13a | 12.0±2.11a | 40.8±2.41ab | 38.8±2.43a | 230.0±12.35e | 1.3±0.11a | 176.1±2.84a |
IN | 11.5±0.50a | 4.5±0.50b | 41.5±2.68ab | 36.0±3.15ab | 340.5±30.83bcd | 1.3±0.03a | 99.0±5.00a |
NLU | 11.7±1.67a | 1.3±0.33b | 46.5±2.50a | 34.5±2.50ab | 454.3±25.65a | 1.3±0.05a | 107.0±9.86a |
编号 | 茎节数 | 茎节间长/mm | 茎节间粗/mm | 芽数 | 隶属函数均值 | 综合排名 | |
PLD | 12.0±2.52a | 2.8±0.14c | 2.2±0.19b | 3.7±0.88b | 0.23 | 8 | |
HLJ | 8.8±1.44a | 10.7±2.10b | 3.0±0.19a | 2.0±0.00b | 0.46 | 4 | |
BYD | 7.5±0.50a | 4.1±0.50c | 2.3±0.15b | 3.5±0.50b | 0.40 | 6 | |
WSH | 13.5±1.56a | 11.7±1.77b | 2.4±0.13b | 4.5±1.60ab | 0.53 | 3 | |
VN | 18.4±1.51a | 13.7±1.59b | 1.6±0.13c | 10.6±1.95a | 0.65 | 1 | |
TH | 21.7±9.33a | 9.8±1.16b | 1.4±0.10c | 5.6±1.51ab | 0.58 | 2 | |
IN | 8.0±0.00a | 10.9±1.69b | 2.3±0.35b | 2.0±0.00b | 0.37 | 7 | |
NLU | 7.0±0.57a | 34.6±2.81a | 1.5±0.13c | 1.3±0.33b | 0.42 | 5 |
[1] | 田代科,张大生.莲叶何田田——世界莲研究进展[J].生命世界,2014,6:40-45. |
[2] | 王其超,张行言.中国荷花品种图志[M].北京:中国林业出版社,2005:2. |
[3] | Shou S Y, Miao L X, Zai W S, et al.Factors influencing shoot multiplication of lotus (Nelumbo nucifera)[J]. Biologia Plantarum,2008,52(3):529-532. |
[4] | 李良俊,何小弟,赵有为,等.莲藕茎尖培养技术的初步研究[J].扬州大学学报:农业与生命科学版,1995,16(3):31-34. |
[5] | 于文进,龙明华,徐烔志.莲藕组织培养及快速繁殖试验研究[J].农业研究与应用,1999(2):9-11. |
[6] | 柯卫东,彭静,刘玉平,等.试管藕诱导技术研究[J].植物科学学报,2001,19(2):173-175. |
[7] | 罗丽萍,郭燕华,蔡奇英,等.经太空诱变的莲藕的组织培养[J].植物生理学报,2004,40(2):201-201. |
[8] | 刁英,吴金平,赵玲玲,等.莲胚性愈伤组织诱导研究初报[J].湖北农业科学,2011,50(14):2991-2992. |
[9] | 柯善强,洪树荣,倪学明,等.美洲黄莲的外植体培养研究初报[J].园艺学报,1987,14(3):208-212. |
[10] | 张建福,王锋.莲藕组织培养与微繁殖技术初探[J].上海农业科技,2002(6):17-18. |
[11] | 郑丽. 荷花胚培养与切花保鲜技术研究[D].武汉:华中农业大学,2010. |
[12] | 刘建平,王芳,杜彩娴,等.荷花幼胚组织培养技术研究[J].现代农业科技,2016(15):140-140. |
[13] | 蔡颖欣,汤宇环,邵晓宇,等.莲子胚培养再生植株及原生质体分离的研究[J].种子,2017,36(3):125-127. |
[14] | 邵文莉. 温度对莲藕组培苗生长代谢影响的试验研究[J].农业科技通讯,2013(2):78-80. |
[15] | 李佳,赵文龙,周长艳,等.莲藕愈伤组织诱导及组织学观察[J].湖北农业科学,2014,53(3):701-703,717. |
[16] | 孔德政. 荷花胚组织培养的初步研究[J].河南科学,2007,25(4):593-595. |
[17] | 徐君,李静会,李欣,等荷花顶芽初代组织培养[J].江苏农业科学,2013,41(3):38-39. |
[18] | 席嘉宾,陈平,张惠霞,等.中国地毯草野生种质资源耐旱性变异的初步研究[J].草业学报,2006,15(3):93-99. |
[19] | Niedz R P.Using isothiazolone biocides to control microbial and fungal contaminants in plant tissue cultures[J]. Horttechnology,1998,8(4):598-601. |
[20] | Lunghusen J.An effective biocide for plant tissue culture[J]. Australian Horticulture,1998,96:45-48. |
[21] | Miyazaki J, Tan B H, Errington S G.Eradication of endophytic bacteria via treatment for axillary buds of Petunia hybrida using Plant Preservative Mixture (PPMTM)[J]. Plant Cell Tissue & Organ Culture,2010,102(3):365-372. |
[22] | Babaoglu M, Yorgancilar M.TDZ-specific plant regeneration in salad burnet[J]. Plant Cell Tissue & Organ Culture,2000,63(1):31-34. |
[23] | Compton M E, Koch J M.Influence of plant preservative mixtureTM PPM on adventitious organogenesis in melon, petunia, and tobacco[J]. In Vitro Cellular & Developmental Biology Plant,2001,37(2):259-261. |
[24] | George M W, Tripepi R R.Plant Preservative MixtureTM can affect shoot regeneration from leaf explants of chrysanthemum, European birch, and rhododendron[J]. HortScience,2001,36(4):768-769. |
[25] | Huh Y S, Lee J K, Kang B G, et al.Effect of biocide addition on plantlet growth and contamination occurrence during the in vitro culture of blueberry[J]. Plant Biotechnology,2015,42(2):111-116. |
[26] | 吕平,张继,檀小辉,等.不同基因型甘蔗离体培养技术研究[J].江苏农业科学,2016,44(10):80-80. |
[27] | 张行言,王其超.热带型荷花的发现与荷花品种分类系统[J].中国园林,2006,22(7):82-85. |
[1] | PU Tianlei, HAN Xueqin, LUO Huiying, DENG Hongshan, LIAO Chengfei, FAN Jiancheng, HE Lu, JIN Jie. Pollen of Moringa oleifera: Germination in vitro [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(9): 66-70. |
[2] | LU Lilan, WANG Yuping, YIN Xinxing, HUANG Yingkai, FAN Haikuo. Investigation and Evaluation of Soil Nutrients in Fruit Coconut Orchards in Hainan Province [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(8): 72-80. |
[3] | HUA Limin, LIU Huiying, XUE Yinghao, LAN Xiping, WANG Yitao, CAI Guangxing. Quantitative Assessment on Comprehensive Effects of Mulching Films by Integrated Evaluation Index Method [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(4): 76-80. |
[4] | CHEN Minmin, NIE Gongping, LI Xin, ZHOU Lin, YANG Liuyan, ZHANG Yongchun. Chlorophyll Fluorescence Characteristics of Lilium spp. Cultivars Under Natural High Temperature [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(29): 86-95. |
[5] | HAN Yanhong, LIU Ruanzhi, YANG Haitang, HU Yanling, LI Pan, ZHU Zhenzhen, SHI Yanzhao, YU Mu. Large-Pod Peanut Varieties in North China: Evaluation and Analysis of Comprehensive Quality [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(24): 14-18. |
[6] | ZHANG Xueting, YUAN Enping, WANG Can, LI Gang, WANG Shaoxiang, LI Yun, ZHAO Shuiling, ZHONG Zhengyang, LI Guiqiong, YANG Di, XIA Pan, XU Cha, ZHAO Changling. Straw for Livestock and Poultry Forage in Wenshan Prefecture of Yunnan Province: Contents and Comprehensive Ranks of Saccharide, Protein and Lipid Nutrients [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(24): 145-150. |
[7] | ZHANG Mengfei, LI Shuang, LI Yunsheng, MA Haixia, LIU Yueqiu. Evaluation on the Drought Resistance of Seedlings of Nine Greening Tree Species [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(20): 38-46. |
[8] | HAN Yanhong, YU Mu, SHI Yanzhao, YANG Haitang, HU Yanling, LIU Ruanzhi, LI Pan, ZHU Zhenzhen. Comprehensive Evaluation of the Quality of 13 Peanut Varieties by Membership Function Method [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(2): 7-11. |
[9] | LI Junping, WANG Xiuping, LIU Sujuan, LU Xuelin, WU Zhe. Salt Tolerance of Maize at Seedling Stage: Identification and Evaluation Method [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(18): 28-34. |
[10] | JIANG Yujie, JIA Qiaojun, JIAO Jie, CHEN Xiliang, MA Cunde, CHANG Hui, LIANG Zongsuo. The Shade Tolerance and Cold Resistance of Polygonatum Germplasm: An Evaluation by Physiological and Biochemical Methods [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2022, 38(13): 96-103. |
[11] | Wang Qinli, Yan Fang, Han Yuqi, Shan Huajia, Song Liru, Feng Yueqin, Wang Zhiwei, Wei Shenglong. Formula of Tomato Seedling Substrate Based on Pleurotus ostreatus Mushroom Bran as the Main Raw Material [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2021, 37(24): 133-138. |
[12] | Wang Xuan, Bian Jianfeng, Yang Minfeng, Du Weimin, Liu Yang, Guo Shiping, Li Bin, Liu Gangcai. Evaluation of Temporal and Spatial Differences of Flue-cured Tobacco Chemical Composition Usability in Sichuan Province Based on Comprehensive Weighting Method [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2021, 37(22): 131-138. |
[13] | Li Simeng, Li Kaifeng, Li Maoxing, Guo Huachun, Wang Qiong. Integrated Assessment of the Tuber Nutritional Quality of New Winter Potato Varieties [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2021, 37(22): 22-27. |
[14] | Liu Bokuan, Zhao Nannan, Cui Shunli, Li Xiukun, Liu Yingru, He Meijing, Hou Mingyu, Yang Xinlei, Mu Guojun, Liu Lifeng. Peanut Varieties: Drought Resistance Identification and Drought Resistance Indices’ Evaluation [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2021, 37(19): 27-35. |
[15] | Huang Zhanwen, Lu Jiashi, Bu Zhaoyang, Li Chunniu, Li Xianmin. The Survival Rate and Growth Characteristics of Grafted Seedling of Camellia azalea with Different Rootstocks [J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2021, 37(10): 54-59. |
Viewed | ||||||
Full text |
|
|||||
Abstract |
|
|||||